The Mark of Excellence

The Mark of Excellence

Send All Love Notes To:

Get Some Steelers Merch

Shop online for Steelers autographs and other great sports memorabilia

Search This Piece

Login, Like A Boss



Social Media Up In This B




Dead Men Walking



Listen to TribLive Radio

Thank You, Sir, May James Harrison Have Another... E-mail
Written by Cotter   
November 04, 2010 13:00


Well, in case you're wondering how Animal House in any way relates to the Steelers and the title of this post (besides being adapted from a line in the above clip), allow me to let highlight the fact that for the third time in five weeks, the NFL has fined James Harrison for an "illegal" hit.

This time, $20,000 for this little number, which WAS at least penalized during the game this time...


You may have noticed that this season, I've basically limited most of my blog posts to previews, recaps and random other crap. I've found that at this point in interwebz history, not everything warrants an entire blog post, assuming you're using the tools available to you effectively (become a fan of OFTOT on Facebook and follow me on Twitter, **cough cough**). Besides, OFTOT has never been about hard news so much as it has been about photojobs and contributing more unnecessary cynicism to the internet. But I figured I'd throw something up about this because it's kind of getting ridiculous.

The question I have is - What's the end game here?

And by that I mean - Ok, so James Harrison is a physical player; we get it. But, is the league trying to use him as an example? Do they think he's been getting away with so-called "dangerous" hits for way too long? I'm not sure.

And how many other guys are getting fined?

Surely in the 13 games on Sunday/Monday, there had to have been more than one "illegal" hit. So, where are those fines? Maybe the league has levied them and I just haven't seen them. But are they going through the tapes from all games and looking at every hit? Or are they singling out James Harrison and looking more or less exclusively at him?

I ask because I legitimately don't know.

I don't like to make someone seem like the victim of some psuedo-conspiracy, but the fact is, it's getting excessive.

He didn't drive Brees to the turf. He didn't hit him helmet-to-helmet, although it appears he led with his head. I mean, that looks like a pretty standard football situation to me. So, what, Silverback is just supposed to put the e-brake on when he's barreling down on Drew Brees at full speed, not knowing whether he actually got rid of the ball or not? He's just finishing his play - including both the tackle and the associated motion to try and strip the ball.

Anyway, the point (I guess) is, this seems like arbitrary punishment, which is of course nothing new to the Roger God-dell administration. If they're trying to send a message to James Harrison, I think it's already been received. But if they're trying to send a message to the rest of the league, maybe they should try delivering it to those other individuals personally, rather than picking on one guy.

Just one man's thoughts.

What do you all think? Have we crossed the line yet? Do you think this particular fine was legit? And why, if he was going to be fined, was Silverback not told that on Tuesday when he met with Heir God-dell?

Oh, and when do you think Silverback's retirement press conference will be?

Give us all your thoughts in the comments!

If you haven't already, become a fan of OFTOT on Facebook, join the blog network and follow Cotter on Twitter. Or don't. Your choice, really.

Comments (9)
  • Erin
    avatar
    I really hope he doesn't retire, but I can't say that I would blame him at this point. It is getting ridiculous. Haters gonna hate....LOL.
  • Gerrimy
    avatar
    There was someone to get fined, Ernie Sims for the Eagles was fined 50k. http://www.cbssports.com/nfl/story/14241414/eagles-lb-sims-plans-to-appeal-fine

    Even still though, the Harrison thing is getting out of hand. I wouldn't be surprised if he went to carson palmer monday night and two and touched him.

    This is really sad that football is coming to this. Every single hit that you make on a popular QB you're gonna have to worry about being fined. Hopefully these guys don't care and will just play football.
  • Cotter
    avatar
    Yeah, I saw that one this afternoon, as well as some Jaguars Safety who got fined $12,500 for a helmet-to-helmet hit - http://nfl.fanhouse.com/2010/11/04/don-carey-fined-12-500-for-hit-on-cowboys-tight-end-jason-witte/
  • louiedoggy  - c'mon man!
    avatar
    This is getting ridiculous, is the NFL starting a charity with Silverbacks money or something??? The man has lost almost 100k for playing a physical game physically. Just because he's better than everyone else doesn't mean he should be punished. C'mon man!
  • Anonymous  - argh
    avatar
    What's wrong is that the $75k hits were fines based on the outcome of the plays - injuries and coincidental injuries in other games that weekend - not Harrison's intent. How can you redefine arbitrary penalties as fine-able offenses? Should a serial false-starter start getting fined because it's unintentionally delaying 60 Minutes?
  • Cotter
    avatar
    Good point. It's really tough to stomach discipline based on unfortunate occurrences and not intent. A penalty is one thing, a fine is another.

    I'm all for keeping guys safe, but that doesn't mean it's time for arbitrary punishment. If you want to eliminate dangerous hits, there should be better rules on what exactly is a "dangerous" hit (for disciplinary purposes) - outside of helmet-to-helmet and whatever else already exists, and also what type of hit draws what type of fine, or at least some idea of what the fine is based on - like some type of scale or something.
  • Grumpy
    avatar
    It was called a penalty on the field; it should be left at that. Any season previous to this one and that would not have been a play on which he was fined.

    Would you inform Harrison of the fine as he sat in your office?
  • tobiathan  - The NFL subconsciously
    avatar
    hates and fears the Steeler-Way.

    They know that Pittsburgh will destroy their opponents virtually every week.

    So- in order to "keep the game in parity" officials(knowingly or not) just "happen" to not notice Silverback being choke-holded, tackled, tripp, facemasked et al. In the ref's mind it's only "fair" to keep that beast-man from ruining the game by nond we have ALL seen thos constantly LATE flags, thrown in AFTER a big play by the Steelers, which immediately negates that big play.

    These flags rarely, if ever, have any video evidence to support tAnd- i'm surprised at how many New York City residents with Italian surnames work in the NFL main offices.

    Might even be a "Saprano" or two there...


  • tobiathan
    avatar

    *Soprano









    .shit.
Only registered users can write comments!
 
Copyright © 2013 One For The Other Thumb. All Rights Reserved.
Joomla! is Free Software released under the GNU/GPL License.