The Mark of Excellence

The Mark of Excellence

Send All Love Notes To:

Get Some Steelers Merch

Shop online for Steelers autographs and other great sports memorabilia

Search This Piece

Login, Like A Boss



Social Media Up In This B




Dead Men Walking



Listen to TribLive Radio

Shaken, Not Stirred... E-mail
Written by Cotter   
April 15, 2010 07:23
likeyahooknowsanything

I realize I'm in the minority here, but I really hope this isn't true.

Of course, let's all realize that it was reported by Yahoo! Sports.

Last time I checked, they weren't exactly the highest profile source on sports in general, let alone the Steelers.

Regardless, let's talk about this whole "shaken" thing.

I hear people saying "we'd rather lose with dignity than win with Big Ben."

Ok.

I wonder if you'll be saying the same thing in a year when the Steelers have gone 5-11 with nothing but 35 year-old Chuck Batch and Dennis Dixon at QB.

The team only went 9-7 this past season, but because they didn't make the playoffs, everybody was acting like someone shit in their cereal.

Dignity.

Ben has nothing to do with us as people.

The only reason you feel he's making you look bad is because you're embracing that notion.

When you accept the idea that Ben reflects you as a person, of course you're going to be offended by his actions.

But Ben doesn't represent me.

He just plays for my favorite football team.

I don't have to think he's a nice guy or even a good guy.

All I have to do is root for the STEELERS.

I've heard some of you say that other fan bases are now making fun of you because of Ben.

Tell them you don't accept his behavior, he disgusts you, but he's your team's QB and you support your team.

There's no rule that says you have to like him as a person.

Besides, this false presumption of guilt has to stop.

They've proven nothing except that he put himself in a couple of bad situations.

The Georgia DA's preacher impression got you thinking Ben got away with something?

He's a prosecutor. That's what he's paid to do. Make people look bad so he can convict them.

He's an elected official. If he stood up there and discussed this thing objectively, he'd be out of a job quicker than you can say Mike Nifong.

You want some real facts?

When the police first interviewed Ben's accuser, right after the incident, when she had a BAC of .20, they asked her if Ben raped her. She said no. Then, only 12-13 hours later, after she had been to the police station and the hospital, and had presumably been asked several more times if Ben raped her, only then did she say that he had sex with her against her will.

Now, I don't know about you, but the day after I've had a BAC of .20, I don't suddenly remember everything that happened the night before like the clouds of inebriation have parted and I've found some divine clarity on my drunken escapades.

Is it possible that these accusations along with the ones made by Andrea McNulty aren't true?

Hell, like Ape pointed out at KSK yesterday, even Jerome Bettis was accused of sexual assault once. You think he did it too?

But I'm not trying to make this girl look bad.

I don't know anything about what happened beyond what I've heard and read.

The bottom line is - We're all human. We all make mistakes.

But this isn't the Boy Scouts of America league, this is the National FOOTBALL League.

You're talking about a QB who has the most wins among any QB in NFL through his first five seasons. A QB who has already won two Super Bowls at 28. The first Steelers QB to throw for more than 500 yards in a game and 4,000 yards in a season. A guy that it takes a yacht anchor of a human being to bring down.

On the field, Ben is among the top players in the NFL.

I just hope you all understand that unlike some other blogs, I refuse to conform to the mob mentality just because it brings me more page views.

I have my own mind, and mine says trading Ben Roethlisberger would be a terrible football decision.

Perhaps you disagree.

There's always going to be two sides to every issue.

And this is mine.

I hope you can respect that.

Thanks in advance.

Go Steelers.

UPDATE: Mike Florio is a tool. Still...
pftoolbox

Here we go.....

If you haven't already, become a fan of OFTOT on Facebook, join the blog network and follow Cotter and Steve on Twitter. Or don't. Your choice, really.

Comments (19)
  • tecmo  - asfhaefeh
    avatar
    Quote:
    But Ben doesn't represent me.

    He just plays for my favorite football team.

    I don't have to think he's a nice guy or even a good guy.

    All I have to do is root for the STEELERS.


    this

    Quote:
    Besides, this false presumption of guilt has to stop.

    They've proven nothing except that he put himself in a couple of bad situations.

    The Georgia DA's preacher impression got you thinking Ben got away with something?

    He's a prosecutor. That's what he's paid to do. Make people look bad so he can convict them.


    and this.

    As Ape mentioned at KSK and we've spoken about via email a few times, it's shocking that people are quick to judge a guy who was cleared of a bogus sexual assault claim from an illgally-drunk-at-a-bar college girl while there's literally NO outrage that Donte Stallworth is going to suit up for an NFL team after getting high and drunk and killing a guy.

    A yearlong suspension from playing a game really makes up for that one guy's life?

    Let he who is without sin cast the first stone. Lotta sinless frauds out there.

    Here we go, STEELERS.
  • Shawn
    avatar
    well said Cotter... totally in agreement...

    tecmo is right about Stallworth too... I can already imagine the pre-game "in-depth" news story that ESPN/Fox/CBS will do next season on Donte and how this tragedy has changed him etc. What a joke!
  • Grumpy
    avatar
    Finally, a voice of sanity. May I reprint this, with proper attribution, on my blog?
  • Cotter
    avatar
    Knock yourself out, brotha!
  • Diego
    avatar
    Finally!!! A Ben related article that doesn't smell like s**t. Well put Cotter
    I can't belive there's a single fan that wants to trade Ben, thats just plain and simple stupidity.
  • Meredith
    avatar
    Well said!! People seem to be throwing the book at Ben so fast that they don't stop to think about which book they're throwing. Well, put, sir =)
  • DG
    avatar
    From a footbal perspective, I agree with you. However, it is not anti-Steeler or presumed guilty thinking to hope that he cleans up his act and stops embarassing the Steelers organization and the NFL off the field. As a parent who had to explain to a 10 year old, football playing son what everybody has been talking about, you must allow for that.
  • Cotter
    avatar
    I never said I don't hope he cleans up his act. I think we all HOPE for that.

    And naturally, I also never said it was anti-Steeler or presuming guilt to say that.

  • Christy
    avatar
    This was so well said, and so well written Cotter. Bravo.

    Can you imagine if Joe Nameth were playing in the NFL today? He wasn't exactly a choir boy back then, if you remember.

    Personally, I'm taking names of any and all of my Steeler fan freinds who want to see Ben traded. IF and when Ben wins us a Superbowl and they try to hop back on the bandwagon, I will be knocking their asses right back off.
  • Doug  - Good Read
    avatar
    I'm just happy I'm not the only Steeler fan not wanting to dump Ben.

    I'm still pissed they dumped Holmes for next to nothing.

    it would be a major setback.

  • LuvSteelers
    avatar
    I agree with you 100%, and I'm a single mom, with 3 daughters.
  • Harbinger Of Doom  - I'm Of Two Minds
    avatar
    On the one hand, I've always taken pride in the fact that the Steelers generally do good things and employ good people.

    On the other, I like them winning a lot more than I care about that.

    He's. Such. A. Douche.

    I can't believe we're even talking about this. What an idiot.

    Ummm...you're Ben Fucking Roethlisberger. Not only do you have so much at stake, but you've probably got a pretty sweet lakefront party palace. Call a few friends! Within two hours you'll have a bar-sized crowd chillin' in the crib, mostly people you trust or at who have at least been vetted by people you trust. You can control events and make sure nothing gets out of hand.

    I think this is him trying to relive the big-time college quarterback atmosphere he was denied at Miami. I'm sure he got his fair share of crumpet, but they certainly don't worship the starting QB there like they do at the other Miami.

    It just drives me crazy that any of these idiots take any of these chances.

    Just hang in there, Big Ben. There'll be plenty of time for you to be a handsy hillbilly biker after football.
  • Sam-I-Am  - Thanks!
    avatar
    I also do NOT want to trade BB. I want him to kick-ass on the field and I want to hear NOTHING about him in the offseason. Been a fan sine the early 70's and I support BB as my QB. I am a mom of an 18 year old and IMHO, BB is guilty of being incredibly stupid, nothing more.
  • Sam-I-Am  - re: Thanks!
    avatar
    Sorry - meant to say mom of 18 year old college GIRL. Geez...
  • Gerrimy  - Finally someone with some sense
    avatar
    These people are really urkin me.
  • tobiathan  - Can we say "Witch Hunt"???
    avatar
    Ben is white. Despite being innocent of any charges a vocal minority of Steeler-haters are playing the race card in saying that it's Ben's "whiteness" that keeps him from being punished.

    If Ben is suspended as a result of an accusation that was declared legally unsupportable it will only be to "prove" that the white players are suspendable too.

    As it is- Ben has done ZERO wrong. Sure, he made some bad decisions, but hasn't broken any law as far as an legal expert can determine.

    Punishing him for being ACCUSED of a "politically incorrect" thing like sexual assualt is horse hit. Particularly when none of the accusers are able to tell the same story twice.

    BTW- The "accusers" are sorority sisters who were deemed too "fugly" to get into Ben VIP area. A little jealousy anybody????
  • tobiathan
    avatar
    Way to keep on keepin' it real, Cotter.
  • domski43
    avatar
    tobiathan makes an appearance ftw! miss you old friend
  • tobiathan  - Greetings old comrades
    avatar
    Reading Cotter's thoughts on this issue have returned me to the fold. I'm sorry I ever doubted his vision. Ben is being used as a tool in a petty, politically-correct tirade by a loud and vocal minority who have a vested interest in seeing the Steelers struggle.

    I've heard and read a lot of schadenfreude on behalf of a lot of those who are shouting for Ben to hang (figuratively speaking). It all sounds like they want to see the guy suffer for having a bad reputation. Last I heard, it was still legal to be an asshole in America. Lucky for me...

    Ben does need to grow up, but to punish him for NOT being charged as a criminal seems like a double-standard to me.
Only registered users can write comments!
 
Copyright © 2013 One For The Other Thumb. All Rights Reserved.
Joomla! is Free Software released under the GNU/GPL License.